2000 Jackson Hole One Fly Event

The Fish Will Probably Spit It Back Out

John Gendall caught 47 Snake River cutthroats Saturday, including three prized, 17-inch trout. The 28-year-old guide from Maruia, New Zealand, enjoyed a similarly enchanting day Sunday on his way to first place and the Vern Bressler Award as the top fly fishing professional.

Gendall had asked friend and Tarantula creator Guy Turck to tie him a One Fly worthy (i.e. very durable) Tarantula for the event. When Guy tried to explain that Tarantulas had not, as of late, been very effective on the stretches John would be fishing, John insisted anyways. So Turck tied Gendall a still secret variation of the Tarantula that drove the formerly Tarantula-indifferent cutthroats into a feeding frenzy. Hint: Color matters!

Yet it was the fish that Gendall didn’t catch — one he helped a competitor with — that had the good-natured Kiwi laughing with amazement at Sunday night’s awards banquet. Earlier that day Gendall had taken part in a whopper of a fish tale, even for a sport known for outrageous stories.

At about 2:30 p.m. guide Gary Beebe of Clacka Craft stopped the boat to do some wading and cast into an appetizing stretch of water in front of a logjam. Boom. Belles drew a strike. The fish appeared to be a big one, about 16 or 17 inches long.

Snap! The fish had gobbled Belles’ fly and tugged so hard it broke the 2X tippet — a heavy-duty line described by Beebe as “big rope.” Belles had lost the fly, earning him instant disqualification from the One Fly. Broken-hearted, he broke down his rod and sulked back to the boat.

The cheery Gendall immediately told Belles not to fret. “It’s a barbless hook and a foam fly,” he said with his ‘down under’ accent. “The fish will probably spit it back out.” Almost on cue, the fly rose to the surface and bobbed in the current. Incredulous, Beebe rushed to the water, but before they could retrieve the lost fly, another fish rose and swallowed it. His faint glimmer of hope extinguished, Belles was devastated. “Tears were coming down my eyes,” he said. The beacon of optimism, Gendall again offered encouragement. “Relax,” he said. “This fish will spit it out, too.”

The three men waited on the banks for two or three minutes before — presto! — “Up comes the fly and we jumped in the river screaming,” Belles said. Belles retrieved and retied the fly, and returned to the boat to resume casting. At the next spot they stopped to wade, Belles landed a 16-inch cutthroat on his first cast. He managed to keep the fly and finished with a respectable 98 points instead of an embarrassing goose egg.

2000 One Fly Event Winning Fly

  John's Skwala Stone

John's Skwala Stone Yet another variation of the old standby Chernobyl, the John's Skwala Stone is a creation of Montana fly tier John Foust who first tied the Madam X fly. One Fly winner Tom Tucker added a red stripe with a magic marker to enhance its appearance!

Tom owes a great deal to his One Fly guide, Brandon Murphy. While using the Skwala and scoring big during the morning, Tom hit a fish just a bit too hard snapping it off. Eagle eyed guide Murphy figured the trout would spit the fly and it did.

Soon the Skwala floated back to the surface where Murphy spotted it floating on the water, before Tom could get it another trout scarped it up. Again the trout rejected the fly and it floated back again. This time, Tom scooped it up, reattached the fly to his leader and proceeded to win the event.

Email the One Fly